Comparison of children and adults undergoing subdural grid electrode implantation or stereoelectroencephalography in a refractory epilepsy cohort from four European centers.

Rados M
Beerepoot S
Pressler RM
Cross JH
Thornton RC
Diehl B
McEvoy AW
Miserocchi A
Sander JW
Duncan JS
de Tisi J
Cardinale F
Tassi L
Russo GL
Francione S
Lamberink HJ
Leijten FSS
Otte WM
van der Salm SMA
Braun KPJ
van Eijsden P

Scientific Abstract

Children with refractory focal epilepsy differ from adults, although many centers will offer invasive electroencephalography (iEEG) to both. Outcomes in terms of likelihood of resection and subsequent seizure outcome after either subdural grid electrode implantation (SDE) or stereoelectroencephalography (SEEG) have, however, not been directly compared between age groups. We retrospectively included adults and children undergoing iEEG monitoring at four European centers. We compared the two age groups and techniques regarding complication rate, chance of proceeding to resection, and seizure freedom. In total, 857 individuals were included (447 SEEG, 410 SDE; 572 adults, 285 children). Adults more often had a history of focal to bilateral tonic-clonic seizures (FBTCS) and prior epilepsy surgery and were more often magnetic resonance imaging-negative. Children had a higher seizure frequency and rate of preexisting neurologic deficits. In SEEG, likelihood of resection was 64% in adults and 76% in children (p < .05), but chance of seizure freedom did not differ. Adults and children had similar chances of resection and seizure freedom rates after SDE. In children, postoperative seizure freedom was less likely after SDE than SEEG. In adults, history of FBTCS was associated with lower chance of seizure freedom. Overall complication rate was higher in children (22% vs. adults 15%) and in SDE (29% vs. SEEG 7%). Either iEEG technique provides an equally valid but very different road to success, with no difference in seizure outcome between the two age groups, but with higher risk of complications in SDE. We found similar surgical results for dissimilar techniques and a higher threshold for children. In case of an assumed lower chance of focality of epilepsy or chance of seizure freedom after resection, adults were more often explored with iEEG, whereas children were more severely affected when considered for iEEG.

Similar content

Preprint
Piper RJ, Fleming JE, van Rheede JJ, Marks VS, Landin K, Costache D, Hasegawa H, Selway R, Richardson H, Seunarine K, D'Arco F, Carter S, Arcaro C, Moeller F, Moulay-Dehbi H, Valentin A, Kaliakatsos M, Denison T, Tisdall MM

Pilot Trial of the Picostim® Deep Brain Stimulation System for Children With Epilepsy: A Prospective, Open-Label Medical Device Study of a System Optimised for Paediatric Neuromodulation

Comparison of children and adults undergoing subdural grid electrode implantation or stereoelectroencephalography in a refractory epilepsy cohort from four European centers.

Rados M
Beerepoot S
Pressler RM
Cross JH
Thornton RC
Diehl B
McEvoy AW
Miserocchi A
Sander JW
Duncan JS
de Tisi J
Cardinale F
Tassi L
Russo GL
Francione S
Lamberink HJ
Leijten FSS
Otte WM
van der Salm SMA
Braun KPJ
van Eijsden P

Scientific Abstract

Children with refractory focal epilepsy differ from adults, although many centers will offer invasive electroencephalography (iEEG) to both. Outcomes in terms of likelihood of resection and subsequent seizure outcome after either subdural grid electrode implantation (SDE) or stereoelectroencephalography (SEEG) have, however, not been directly compared between age groups. We retrospectively included adults and children undergoing iEEG monitoring at four European centers. We compared the two age groups and techniques regarding complication rate, chance of proceeding to resection, and seizure freedom. In total, 857 individuals were included (447 SEEG, 410 SDE; 572 adults, 285 children). Adults more often had a history of focal to bilateral tonic-clonic seizures (FBTCS) and prior epilepsy surgery and were more often magnetic resonance imaging-negative. Children had a higher seizure frequency and rate of preexisting neurologic deficits. In SEEG, likelihood of resection was 64% in adults and 76% in children (p < .05), but chance of seizure freedom did not differ. Adults and children had similar chances of resection and seizure freedom rates after SDE. In children, postoperative seizure freedom was less likely after SDE than SEEG. In adults, history of FBTCS was associated with lower chance of seizure freedom. Overall complication rate was higher in children (22% vs. adults 15%) and in SDE (29% vs. SEEG 7%). Either iEEG technique provides an equally valid but very different road to success, with no difference in seizure outcome between the two age groups, but with higher risk of complications in SDE. We found similar surgical results for dissimilar techniques and a higher threshold for children. In case of an assumed lower chance of focality of epilepsy or chance of seizure freedom after resection, adults were more often explored with iEEG, whereas children were more severely affected when considered for iEEG.

Citation

2025. Epilepsia, 66(8):2715-2727.

DOI

10.1111/epi.18443

Free Full Text at Europe PMC

PMC12371617

Downloads

View PDF (2MB)

Similar content

Preprint
Piper RJ, Fleming JE, van Rheede JJ, Marks VS, Landin K, Costache D, Hasegawa H, Selway R, Richardson H, Seunarine K, D'Arco F, Carter S, Arcaro C, Moeller F, Moulay-Dehbi H, Valentin A, Kaliakatsos M, Denison T, Tisdall MM

Pilot Trial of the Picostim® Deep Brain Stimulation System for Children With Epilepsy: A Prospective, Open-Label Medical Device Study of a System Optimised for Paediatric Neuromodulation